Pay in dollars or the local currency? What to tap when the card machine asks
When a card machine or ATM abroad offers to charge you in US dollars, say no and pay in the local currency. Here's how to spot the offer, what the screen has to show you, and what to do if you already said yes.
No. When a card machine, ATM or hotel desk abroad offers to charge you in US dollars instead of the local currency, decline it and pay in euros, pounds, yen or whatever the local money is. That offer is called dynamic currency conversion, or DCC, and the exchange rate comes from the shop's or ATM's payment provider rather than from your own card. Saying no is always allowed, it never stops the payment going through, and it hands the conversion back to your card, which is usually the cheaper route.
Your personalized guide for Italy, Spain or Greece puts the money side of your trip next to the entry rules and the apps worth having, all for your own dates and passport.
What the offer looks like
It rarely says "dynamic currency conversion". It usually looks like a friendly question. A card terminal might show two buttons, one in euros and one in dollars, with the dollar amount worked out for you. An ATM might show your withdrawal "in USD" and ask you to accept its conversion rate. A waiter might ask, quite kindly, "Would you like to pay in dollars?"
The dollar figure feels reassuring because you can see exactly what you're paying. That's the whole appeal, and it's also where the cost hides. Visa describes it as an option to pay in your home currency "which includes exchange rate and additional fees."
Why we always say no
When you choose the local currency, your card's network and your own bank do the conversion. When you choose dollars, the conversion is done by whoever runs the terminal or the ATM. Visa's rules for card terminals put it plainly: DCC "is not a Visa service." It's offered by the merchant's bank or a DCC company, and they set the rate.
So the question isn't really "dollars or euros". It's "my bank's rate, or the terminal's rate". If your card has no foreign transaction fee, your bank's rate is the one we'd pick every time. The terminal's rate already has the provider's markup built in, and you're the one paying for it. Our post on avoiding foreign transaction fees covers how to check what your own card charges abroad.
You're always allowed to decline
This is the part that matters most when you're standing at a counter with a queue behind you. Visa's consumer page says merchants and ATMs "should give you a choice to accept or decline currency conversion and must not choose on your behalf," and that accepting or declining "will not impact your ability to make purchases or withdraw cash internationally."
Its rules for terminals go further. You "must actively choose the DCC option" before the payment is processed, and if you refuse, the merchant or ATM "must process the transaction in their local currency."
So if a terminal has already picked dollars, or a cashier hands you a machine with the dollar amount on it, you can ask them to cancel and run it again in the local currency. Do it before you tap or enter your PIN. Once the payment goes through, it's much harder to undo.
What the screen has to show you
Visa says merchants and ATMs that offer the conversion have to show you:
- the amount in both the local currency and your home currency, with both currency symbols;
- the exchange rate they're using;
- any extra fee or markup.
The same page says they shouldn't use tricks like a different font size or color to steer you towards one option. If those details are missing, or you feel pushed, Visa recommends declining the conversion and reporting it to your card issuer.
In the EU, the markup has to be a percentage
Inside the European Union there's an extra rule that makes the cost easier to see. EU law on cross-border payments says anyone offering currency conversion at an ATM or at the point of sale has to show the total conversion charge as a percentage markup over the European Central Bank's latest euro reference rate, before you pay. They also have to show you the amount in both currencies and give you the option to pay in the local currency instead.
That percentage is the number to look for on the screen anywhere in the EU, from Italy and Spain to Greece and Croatia. It tells you how much more you'd pay than the ECB's reference rate. As an example of the arithmetic, a 6 percent markup on a 200 euro hotel bill would be about 12 euros on top, before anything your own bank does. The ECB publishes its reference rates every working day if you want to see the rate the markup is measured against.
Outside the EU, in the UK, Mexico or Japan for example, that EU percentage rule doesn't apply. Visa's own requirements to show the rate and let you choose still do.
Where it catches people
Most people meet DCC at the obvious places, the restaurant table and the airport ATM. These are the ones we'd watch more closely, because they're easy to rush:
- Hotel checkout. A big bill, a tired traveler, and a receipt already printed in dollars. Ask for it in the local currency before you sign.
- Car rental counters. Same idea, sometimes set up at the start of the rental. Check the paperwork for a currency choice.
- Standalone ATMs in tourist areas. Our ATM fees post explains why we use machines at real bank branches instead.
- Restaurant card machines brought to the table. The screen often faces you for a moment only. Slow down and read it.
- Foreign websites. Some offer to show and charge your booking in dollars. The same logic applies: pick the local currency if you're given the choice.
If you already said yes
It's an easy mistake. If you accepted the conversion by mistake, there's no undo button at the till once the payment has gone through, so you may simply have paid a bit more this time.
If you weren't given a real choice, the terminal chose for you, or the screen didn't show the rate and markup, that's different. Visa's advice is to report it to your card issuer. Call the number on the back of your card, say the merchant applied currency conversion without your consent, and keep the receipt. Whether you get anything back is your bank's decision, not ours to promise, but reporting it is the step the card network itself points you to.
Our country posts
The same rule comes up in every country we cover. Our posts on paying in Italy, Spain, Croatia and Greece explain when you'll still want cash, card minimums and surcharges, and the local rules that sit next to this one.
What we'd do
Every time a screen, a machine or a person offers us dollars, we say no and pay in the local currency. We read the screen before we tap, we ask for it to be run again if a terminal has picked dollars for us, and we use a card with no foreign transaction fee so the local currency really is the cheaper choice. It's your money and your call, but we've never found a reason to say yes.
Payment rules and card fees change, so check your own card's foreign fees before you fly. Then let your Italy, Spain or Greece guide take care of the rest: the entry rules for your passport, the apps to have on your phone, and how to get from the airport you're actually landing at.
Reddi is free and independent. If it helped, you can support it.
Read this next
Full checklists for these destinations
Skip the research, get your own checklist
Enter your destination and passport for a free checklist built around your trip: entry rules, the apps that actually work there, safety notes, and what to pack. Two minutes, no signup needed.
